white ceramic bathtub near green potted plant

Most people think of the bathroom as one of the cleanest rooms in the house. It’s where we shower, brush our teeth, and get ready for the day. But experts warn that some of the items you use every single morning could quietly be making you ill.

Heat, moisture, and poor ventilation are everything bacteria, mold, and mildew need to grow. The result: the very things we use to keep ourselves clean often become some of the dirtiest items in the home — and can contribute to skin irritation, eye infections, stomach bugs, and respiratory problems if they aren’t replaced on time.

Faz Salloo, bathroom specialist at Bathroom Fort, has rounded up the seven items most Americans are keeping in their bathroom for far too long.

  1. Loofahs and shower sponges

Loofahs feel clean because they’re abrasive. They aren’t. The landmark 1994 study published in the Journal of Clinical Microbiology — still cited in dermatology research today — traced a case of Pseudomonas aeruginosa folliculitis directly to a contaminated loofah and found the sponges harbor Pseudomonas, Klebsiella, and Streptococcus within days of first use.

“People treat loofahs like they’re permanent fixtures. They’re not,” said Salloo. “If you’ve had yours longer than a month, you’re not exfoliating — you’re rubbing a bacterial colony into your skin.”

Plastic puffs should be replaced every three to four weeks. Natural loofahs every three.

  1. Your toothbrush — and where it lives

The average toothbrush contains more than 10 million bacteria, according to research from the University of Manchester — including E. coli and staph. A separate study found that more than half of toothbrushes stored in shared bathrooms tested positive for fecal coliform bacteria, with an 80% chance the bacteria came from someone else’s body.

The culprit is “toilet plume”: when a toilet is flushed with the lid up, contaminated droplets can travel as much as 15 feet through the air and settle on every nearby surface, according to research by NYU microbiologist Philip Tierno. Close the lid before flushing, keep brushes in a closed cabinet, and replace them every three months. Toothbrush covers actually make it worse — they trap moisture.

  1. Damp towels

Dr. Charles Gerba, a University of Arizona microbiologist known as “Dr. Germ,” has found that 90% of bathroom towels are contaminated with coliform bacteria, 14% carry E. coli, and some contain Salmonella. An Inside Edition lab test of one used towel found bacteria counts jumped from 260,000 on day one to 650 million by day seven.

“After about two days, if you dry your face on a hand towel, you’re probably getting more E. coli on your face than if you stuck your head in a toilet and flushed it,” Gerba told TIME.

Wash bath towels in hot water every three days. If they still smell musty after a hot wash, the fibers are past saving.

  1. Plastic shower curtains and liners

The pink slime at the bottom of a shower curtain is a bacterial film called Serratia marcescens — generally harmless to healthy adults but a documented infection risk for anyone with cuts, contact lenses, or a weakened immune system. Replace plastic liners every six months, or wash monthly with a cup of white vinegar on a warm cycle.

  1. The bath mat

The CDC warns that prolonged exposure to indoor mold can trigger asthma attacks, allergic reactions, and respiratory infections — and the bath mat is one of the first places mold takes hold in any bathroom. Trapped water under rubber-backed mats can’t evaporate, and the underside becomes a hidden colony of mold spores within weeks. Wash weekly on a hot cycle, and replace the moment dark spots appear.

  1. The toilet brush

One of the dirtiest tools in your house lives in a plastic cup, dripping. Most people never clean the brush itself, which means every use redistributes whatever has grown on it.

“This is the one people forget exists between uses,” said Salloo. “Every two weeks, leave the brush soaking in diluted bleach in the bowl for an hour. Replace the whole thing every six months. It costs about ten bucks.”

  1. Expired makeup and skincare

Most people throw out food the day it expires but keep mascara for two years. Research published in the Journal of Applied Microbiology has repeatedly found used cosmetics — particularly mascara, lip gloss, and beauty blenders — contaminated with Staphylococcus, E. coli, and other pathogens. Clear the cabinet every six months: anything past its date, anything that’s changed color or smell, and anything you haven’t used in a year.

“A clean-looking bathroom isn’t the same thing as a clean bathroom,” Salloo added. “Almost everything on this list costs under $20 to replace — and a hell of a lot more in skin infections and doctor visits if you don’t.”